HomeEnglishINDIA Bloc Leaders File “Interrogatories” in SC to Question CEC, ECs under...

INDIA Bloc Leaders File “Interrogatories” in SC to Question CEC, ECs under Oath

Manas Dasgupta

NEW DELHI, Nov 16: Even as the BJP continued to target the Congress terming as “treason” the Italian politician Giacomo Filibeck’s remarks on “Vote Chori” in India at the Congress organised “Bharat Summit” in Hyderabad, the Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders on Monday filed an affidavit in the Supreme Court seeking a nod to serve a set of ‘interrogatories’ on the Election Commission, asking it to answer questions under oath on the decision-making process in the nationwide SIR of electoral rolls .

In the application filed in his pending petition, Gandhi and others have sought sworn responses from the Deputy Election Commissioner, who had filed the poll panel’s counter-affidavit, the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar and the two Election Commissioners on specific issues concerning the authorisation of SIR, alleged exclusion of voters and changes made to the Commission’s online electoral registration systems.

The affidavit was submitted a day ahead of the scheduled hearing. The opposition has prepared a list of 48 questions for the purpose. The opposition leaders have sought permission to personally question CEC Gyanesh Kumar, both Election Commissioners and the Director General of IT within the poll body. They have also prepared a list of 48 questions for the Election Commission of India (ECI). The INDIA bloc has alleged that the ECI’s affidavit failed to address key questions about allegations of ‘vote theft’ and the revision of electoral rolls.

The Supreme Court is hearing petitions challenging the actions of the CEC and the Election Commission of India (ECI) over the nationwide Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. The petitioners, including Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and advocate Vikas Singh, have alleged that CEC Gyanesh Kumar took unilateral decisions during the SIR exercise without the consent or concurrence of the other two Election Commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. They have also raised concerns over changes made to Form 6.

The plea questioned whether the Election Commission, as a collective body, made decisions on the nationwide special intensive revision (SIR) or whether the chief election commissioner exercised the EC’s powers without the knowledge, approval, or concurrence of the other Election Commissioners. Gandhi and others also questioned the absence of a recorded EC decision authorising the nationwide exercise, modifications to online Form 6, and the functioning of the ECINET and ERONET electoral-roll databases, which the petitioners describe as centralised and opaque.

The plea listed 48 questions for the EC, the CEC and officials on the decision-making process behind nationwide SIR. Gandhi and others have sought details of upgrades and alterations made to the EC’s portal, including the identity of persons responsible for carrying them out.

The plea referred to EC’s admission that the declaration was incorporated into the online version of Form 6 and said the poll panel’s reply did not identify persons authorising the changes.

“Allow the present application and grant leave to the Petitioners to deliver to the Respondents the interrogatories set out in …hereto and direct that the same be answered by way of Affidavit by persons of such identity as set out therein; and that copies of the records referred to in the answers be annexed thereto, and that any claim of privilege be stated specifically, record by record, with the grounds thereof, for adjudication by this Hon’ble Court,” the plea said.

Last month, a bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant refused to grant interim relief seeking Kumar’s suspension, observing that the court could not pass an ex-parte order or remove the head of the poll panel based solely on media reports without examining official records.

The Supreme Court subsequently issued notices to the ECI, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, the other Election Commissioners and the Centre, seeking their responses. In response, the ECI and the three Election Commissioners filed a joint counter-affidavit spanning nearly 250 pages, maintaining that all major decisions during the SIR process were taken unanimously.

They argued that any attempt to restrain the CEC from discharging his duties would be contrary to law, asserting that the CEC can be removed only through the same constitutional procedure and on the same grounds applicable to a Supreme Court judge.

The EC, in its 248-page response to the petitions against the CEC and the decisions taken by it, defended the SIR. Rejecting the allegations that Form 6 had been amended, the poll body said no changes were made to the statutory Form 6 used for voter registration. Form 6 is an application through which an eligible person seeks inclusion in the electoral rolls, it said.
“The attempt to make aspersions against the Election Commission is unfortunate,” said the affidavit, filed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu on behalf of the EC.

The EC said the affidavit itself had been approved for filing by a unanimous decision of all three members of the poll body. It said the SIR orders of June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025 and May 14, 2026 were issued on unanimous decisions taken in compliance with Article 324 of the Constitution and Section 18 of the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.

Meanwhile, the BJP national spokesman Gaurav Bhatia on Monday attacking Rahul Gandhi said it was misfortune for India that the Congress MP was the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, a constitutional office. He said Gandhi was acting out of frustration because of repeated failure in elections.

“Look at the misfortune: a foreigner challenges and mocks India’s mandate from an Indian platform. It is India’s misfortune that its LoP is Rahul Gandhi. Rahul Gandhi did not stop Giacomo Filibeck; Rahul Gandhi did not say that it is our internal matter and Filibeck should not make comments on it. Rahul Gandhi clapped with a smile on his face; he laughed,” he said.

“Rahul Gandhi, while losing elections, is getting swept away in the hatred for Narendra Modi. He made his party lose 99 elections. This is his frustration. Rahul Gandhi has just one goal – to defame India,” he added.

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular