HomeEnglishSiraj Exclusion: Congress MP Snubbed by Party Colleague, AIMIM Supports

Siraj Exclusion: Congress MP Snubbed by Party Colleague, AIMIM Supports

Manas Dasgupta

NEW DELHI, Nov 21: Political controversy in cricket over the exclusion of ace pacer Mohammad Siraj from the Indian team in the first test against New Zealand being played in Wellington, refuses to die down with several politicians and former cricketers commenting on for and against the team selection process.

The Congress MP Imran Masood who had kicked up the controversy alleging that Siraj was not picked in the team only because he was a Muslim, was on satuday reprimanded by a fellow party MP. Congress Rajya Sabha MP Ranjeet Ranjan criticised Masood’s remarks and advised him against bringing religion into sports.

“I would simply urge Masoodji to keep politics and sports separate. Please, let us not interfere in sports. Sports has its own domain, its own criteria for merit, and every player has their own unique struggle. I strongly believe that while we may engage in political manoeuvring, we should not drag sports or athletes into our political discourse. I find that completely unacceptable,” Ranjan said, reacting to Masood’s comments.

Mr Masood had claimed that the fast bowler was not picked in the playing XI despite his impressive performances because of his name. “It is being said that despite his good performance, he was not given a place in the team. His name is ‘Siraj’, and that is why he was not given a place. If you are not selecting him despite his good performance, the discrimination is clear,” Mr Masood had alleged.

Hitting back at Masood, BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari accused the Congress of indulging in “vote-bank politics” even over the selection of the cricket team. “Shame on Congress! Congress now does vote-bank politics even in cricket team selection! Congress says – ‘Siraj was left out because he was a Muslim.’ Even Jadeja was left out! Every cricketer wears the jersey representing India! Stop dividing Indian cricket team for vote-bank and communal politics!” Bhandari posted on social media.

Masood, however, remained defiant amid the backlash. On Saturday, he cited the names of other Muslim cricketers, including Mohammed Shami and Sarfaraz Khan, to reinforce his allegations of discrimination. “There’s Mohammed Shami, there’s Sarfaraz, and many others. Selections should be based on performance. If someone is performing well, it shouldn’t matter where they come from,” Masood said on Saturday.

Masood found a supporter in AIMIM leader Waris Pathan who also questioned whether team selection was being determined by talent and performance or a player’s name. “The same happened with Sarfaraz. The same happened with Md Shami. Now, Siraj plays with a positive mindset, steps up whenever the team needs him, and performs exceptionally well. Everything is going in his favour, so why isn’t he being selected? Why has he been benched? One has to ask: will selection now be based on talent and performance, or will it be based on someone’s name?” Pathan said.

The Union Minister Kiren Rijiju rejected the allegations asserting that opportunities in the country are given based on merit and not religion or caste. “…Nobody here is discriminated against or overlooked on the basis of their religion. In our country, opportunities are given based on merit. One’s religion or caste has nothing to do with it. If someone feels this way, it is not right,” the Union Minister said while speaking to reporters.

Meanwhile, cricketing greats Sunil Gavaskar and Ravi Shastri had also questioned Siraj’s exclusion from the playing XI for the ongoing first Test against New Zealand, arguing that the team management should have taken the pacer’s experience into account but without referring to his religion. While Gavaskar described Siraj’s exclusion as baffling, Shastri said on social media that the pacer should have been included, given his experience and work ethic.

However, Captain Shubman Gill and batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the team management’s decision, maintaining that the best possible playing XI had been selected for the Test. Speaking about the players left out, Gill said: “Quite tough, you know. We were contemplating for the past one week which combination to go with because all of our fast bowlers have been doing really well. Very difficult for Siraj and Gurnoor, both of them, to miss out.”

Kotak also defended the decision to leave Siraj out of the playing XI. “There is nothing wrong with Siraj. We thought this was the best XI when we picked the side. I don’t think dropping Siraj was a wrong decision,” Kotak told reporters on Thursday.

Former India captain Kapil Dev has refused to make any adverse comment on the team selection stating that he was not authorised to speak on the issue and said “selectors were doing a great job.” Asked about Imran Masood’s comment Kapil Dev said, “Ask the selectors. I am nobody. Look, people like us should not comment. If the group of people who have that responsibility, they should answer. I think they are doing a great job. We can’t make everybody happy,” he told reporters.

You can’t criticise a system because the system is built like that. Let’s say, Indian cricket is doing well; That’s more important. I like him, but I think it is the selector, manager and the captain who have to pick. Our liking and disliking should not matter, but how the organisation is planning,” Kapil Dev added.

Another former India star Mohammad Kaif, however, also criticised the selection process stating that Siraj’s seniority and experience should have been taken into account over other pace bowlers in selecting the team. Alleging that the current team management did not care about seniority or past records, Kaif said, “It is very common in this management. If you have performed poorly for two to three matches… even if Sachin Tendulkar was part of this team, this management, as a player, if he had done poorly in two or three matches, even questions would have been asked of him. Maybe he would have been dropped too,” Kaif said.

Kaif added that Siraj did not do well during India’s last Test series in Sri Lanka in August. Siraj took four wickets in two matches. “Their memory is very recent. I know he did not do well in Sri Lanka. His pace was low too. But in Asia, Ravichandran Ashwin and Ravindra Jadeja have been the wicket-taking options. In Sri Lanka, Ravindra Jadeja and Manav Suthar bowled the majority of the overs in Colombo,” he said.

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular