Manas Dasgupta
NEW DELHI, Nov 17: The Supreme Court on Tuesday agreed to have a detailed hearing of an application of ‘interrogatories’ filed by the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders, who have posed 48 questions directly to Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, and senior poll officials regarding the “Special Intensive Revision” (SIR) of electoral rolls.
The interrogatories challenge the veracity of “bare assertions” made by the Election Commission of India (ECI) in an institutional affidavit filed on October 26. One of these assertions was that the decision to hold a nationwide SIR, which saw around 13 crore voters excluded from the electoral rolls, was “unanimous.”
Mr Gandhi had told the Supreme Court on Monday that the ECI failed to produce any proof to establish its claim that the SIR was a “unanimous” decision made by the CEC and the two ECs. “No minutes of the meeting, file notings, recorded approvals, agenda, deliberations or other primary material evidencing the participation and approval of all three members have been produced with the ECI counter-affidavit of October 26,” Mr Gandhi submitted in his rejoinder.
The interrogatories intend to compel the two Election Commissioners to individually state on oath whether they had objected to the SIR orders. The interrogatories require the CEC, the Election Commissioners, and poll officials to support their every answer with documentary proof in court.
A Bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant posted the case for December 9 after senior advocate Harish Salve, appearing for the ECI, enquired if the court would have enough time to hear the multiple petitions in the post-lunch session.
Senior advocates Kapil Sibal, A.M. Singhvi and advocate Prasanna S., for the INDIA bloc leaders, urged the Bench, which was about to rise for lunch after the morning session when Mr Salve intervened, to issue notice on the application containing the interrogatories.
Though, initially, the court agreed to issue notice to the ECI for a response, Mr Salve, along with senior advocate Maninder Singh, opposed the issuance of any notice before a preliminary hearing on the application. “We will then hear the application and pass necessary orders,” the CJI said.
The application was filed as part of the Opposition leaders’ writ petition claiming the nationwide SIR exercise, the manner and extent of its conduct, was the product of a unilateral exercise of power by the CEC without the knowledge, approval or concurrence of the Election Commissioners.
Mr Gandhi and the Opposition leaders submitted that posing the interrogatories was necessary as the controversy in their petition substantially rested upon facts that lie exclusively within the knowledge and the records of the ECI. The petitioners said they had no means of access to those facts except through the ECI and their officials. So far, rather than disclosing those facts, the ECI has only made bare assertions.
The Opposition leaders said though the Supreme Court was not fettered by any rigid procedure, ‘interrogatories’ were recognised by the Supreme Court Rules Further, the court was empowered by the Rules to pass any orders “necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the court.”
The interrogatories covered detailed ground, including whether the October 26 affidavit claiming that SIR was a “unanimous decision” was ever placed before Mr Sandhu and Mr Joshi. If so, when and how, and if they had suggested any changes in any assertions made in the document.
The Opposition leaders have asked for the number of the file clearing a nationwide SIR in which the decision of the Commission was taken, the date of the decision, whether it was taken at a meeting, upon circulation of a file or through electronic means, and the date on which each member signified approval.
They have queried about the contradictory stands taken by the ECI in the October 26 affidavit and an earlier Right to Information (RTI) reply from the poll body that had said “the Commission has so far not taken any decision on initiating an SIR across the country in 2025.”
Moreover, the INDIA bloc leaders have also asked the number of occasions, between February 19 last year to October 26, 2026, on which the two Election Commissioners allegedly recorded their written objections, dissent or reservation concerning any matter relating to the SIR, ECINET, Form 6 or the filing of appeals.
The petitioner-leaders have sought the total number of appeals pending in tribunals against the re-inclusion of names in West Bengal. “They have also sought the names and designations of each officer who decided to institute these appeals and who signed or filed them.
“State whether any instruction, guideline, standard operating procedure or criterion for selecting the orders of inclusion to be appealed against was issued by the Commission, the Chief Electoral Officer, West Bengal, or any other authority; and, if so, furnish its particulars,” they sought.
The Opposition leaders have asked whether ECINET had maintained an audit trail recording from June 24 last year, for every addition, deletion, modification and restoration of an entry, the user account, the date and time, and the order of the Electoral Registration Officer under which it was made.
The petitioners have sought information on whether any Member of the ECI had “objected to the incorporation of the Declaration (seeking mapping details) in the online Form 6; and, if so, state the date of each objection and the manner in which it was dealt with.”
They also asked for details from each State and Union Territory on the number of objections received under Form 7 (for deletion of voters from the electoral roll), how many of these objections were found to be false or filed in the names of non-existent persons, and if any action had been taken under the Representation of the People Act, 1950.
The reported friction between Mr Kumar and the two Election Commissioners over the SIR and the CEC’s allegedly unilateral and authoritarian conduct, had triggered widespread protests across India demanding his removal from office.
The ECI’s October 26 affidavit, in response to a petition filed by INDIA bloc leaders led by Mr Gandhi, had denied any differences of opinion between the CEC and the Election Commissioners over the SIR process. Mr Gandhi said the court must not accept such “bare assertions” from the ECI. He questioned why the affidavit was filed by the ECI when Mr Kumar, Mr Sandhu and Mr Joshi were separately made respondents.
The Opposition leader, represented by senior advocate A.M. Singhvi and advocate Prasanna S., said the EC chose not to explain when and where exactly the decision to conduct a nationwide SIR was made. The ECI affidavit’s blank assertions contradict its own Right to Information (RTI) response that “the Commission has so far not taken any decision on initiating a special intensive revision (SIR) across the country in 2025”.
Mr Gandhi said the ECI’s claim of a “unanimous” Commission did not quite agree with the fact that Mr Sandhu and Mr Joshi took the unprecedented step of writing directly to the Cabinet Secretary, conveying their displeasure over the conduct of affairs within the poll body during the SIR exercise.
“That two members of the Commission found it necessary to address the Cabinet Secretary, and to issue a joint direction of their own, is itself inconsistent with the picture of unanimous functioning,” the LoP said, adding their communications cannot be brushed aside as “internal differences or administrative exchanges.”
Mr Gandhi questioned the logic behind the EC’s claim that the additional declaration form annexed to the statutory Form 6 was separate and “not a part of Form 6.” He pointed out that the declaration “was entered into the online page of Form 6” and that the online application and declaration were combined for the purpose of a single OTP and electronic signature.
“An applicant accessing the online Form 6 process was required to encounter and complete the additional declaration as part of that process,” his rejoinder argued. He highlighted the statements made by the ECI in its October 26 affidavit that over 16 lakh appeals against inclusion of voters in West Bengal were filed by officers of the State’s Chief Electoral Office, and that too, without consulting the poll body.
“This confirms the very grievance reportedly raised by the Election Commissioners, namely, that appeals were filed in the name of the Commission without the knowledge of its Members,” Mr Gandhi contended. If not, the ECI has to bring on record relevant approvals for filing such appeals against inclusions in the West Bengal electoral roll.
The LoP said the ECI’s explanations about ECINET and ERONET, the digital platforms managing voter registration and electoral rolls, failed to address specific concerns raised in court about their design, configuration, operation and control. The petitioners argued that the functioning of ECINET and ERONET systems was both centralised and opaque, which led to large-scale exclusion of electors.
Mr Gandhi urged the court to note that the ECI was “entirely silent” on several issues like the reduction of approximately 20.66 lakh names from the electoral roll of Punjab, the non-availability of the orders and guidelines governing the 2003 intensive revision used as a benchmark for mapping electors, the bulk filing of objections in Form 7, including in allegedly forged names, and the analysis indicating that women constituted approximately 62% of the electors excluded in West Bengal.
“The present proceedings cannot be disposed of on the basis of general denials or subsequent explanations and showcasing of woefully belated course-correction,” Mr Gandhi had requested the court.


