HomeEnglishSC Reprimands Authorities over Increasing Pollution in Yamuna River as BJP-AAP Spar

SC Reprimands Authorities over Increasing Pollution in Yamuna River as BJP-AAP Spar

Manas Dasgupta

NEW DELHI, Nov 16: Despite politics over cleaning the Yamuna River with the Delhi’s incumbent ruling party the BJP and its predecessor the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) continued to spar with each other over pollution, the Supreme Court has reprimanded the authorities pointing out that the pollution in Yamuna has only increased despite huge sums being spent on cleaning the river and directed the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) to monitor water quality at the points where the Yamuna and its major drains enter and exit states, Union territories and districts.

In an order dated November 4, which was uploaded on Monday, a Bench of Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan observed that industrial pollutants and untreated sewage must be stopped at the source, and merely constructing more sewage treatment plants was not sufficient to clean the river.

The bench questioned the authorities over pollution and warned that states, union territories (UTs) and authorities that fail to stop pollution in Yamuna would face penalties. “Everything that is wrong with civic administration in the towns, cities and villages situated along the banks of the river is reflected in the poor health of the river and in the 520 (five hundred twenty) drains’ that discharge wastewater into the Yamuna. This is why, despite huge sums being spent on cleaning the river, pollution in the Yamuna has only increased,” the bench said.

On industrial pollution and untreated sewage, the top court observed that they must be curtailed “if not stopped altogether” at the source. Where that is not possible, the sewage must first be tapped and then treated; however, tapping will remain a challenge in absence of a robust sewage system and due to joining of storm-water and sewage drains, the court said.

“This court is further of the opinion that it would be difficult, if not impossible, for civic authorities to tap sewage in most illegal and unauthorised colonies built on encroached land, since they have not been built on a grid layout and have hardly any space for laying a sewage system,” it said.

The apex court said unless illegal and unauthorised colonies and ‘jhuggi-jhopdi’ (slum) clusters on the drains as well as on the river bed are removed, with rehabilitation of their occupants, their sewage will continue to pollute the river. The court directed that if water quality deteriorates while passing through a particular state, Union territory or district, the concerned authorities would be held accountable and penalised.

“If the water quality deteriorates on any parameter while flowing through, or exiting a state/Union territory or a district therein, that state/Union territory or district… shall be held accountable and penalised. The said compensation/ fine shall be deposited with the registry of this court,” the Bench said, directing CPCB to suggest a formula for calculating the said compensation.

The top court also directed the CPCB to investigate and submit a detailed report with respect to any incident of pollution in the Yamuna, such as fish deaths, floating of white foam on the surface, eutrophication or algal bloom, or increase in Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD), Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD), or Total Suspended Solids (TSS) levels.

“The report should specifically mention the cause of such an incident or spike in pollution levels as well as remedial measures to be undertaken,” it said. The apex court directed all central and state bodies, including Ministries and agencies, to render all necessary administrative, logistical, technical, operational and infrastructural assistance to CPCB, its officers, and expert institutions engaged by it, without delay.

“All public and private entities, concessionaires, operators, and agencies managing, operating, or maintaining wastewater, solid waste, and effluent treatment infrastructure, shall grant immediate, unhindered, and unconditional access to their premises, installations, and records to the officials of CPCB and its designated third-party agencies at all hours, for the purposes of unannounced inspections, surprise sample collection, volumetric audits, sensor verifications, and technical assessments.

“All concerned departments, authorities, concessionaires, and plant operators shall extend full technical cooperation and complete, unrestricted data access to the CPCB, ensuring seamless and uninterrupted integration with the centralised monitoring architecture of the CPCB within the time frames stipulated by this court,” the Bench said.

“This Court is of the opinion that Zone ‘O’, as defined in the Delhi Master Plan 2047, should not only be maintained and protected as a ‘Green’ Zone but should also be extended upstream and downstream if feasible, that is, from the source of the river Yamuna to its confluence with the river Ganga. No permanent structure, except green parks and essential public infrastructure projects, should be allowed to be constructed in future in the said or extended Zone,” it said.

“Even for recreational and tourism purposes, only semi-permanent structures, such as cycling and walking tracks, should be permitted; permanent structures may be constructed only outside Zone ‘O’ and that too at a suitable height. Efforts should be made to remove all structures existing in Zone ‘O’, or in the proposed extended Zone, in accordance with the extant law and after allocating alternative accommodation to the occupants, where they are so entitled. After all, the river Yamuna must have space to meander and change its course, if it so chooses,” it added.

The matter has been listed for hearing on January 13.

Meanwhile, ignoring the top court’s strong observations, the BJP government in Delhi continued to take credit for “cleaning” Yamuna and accused the predecessor AAP of deliberately dumping dead fishes in the river to defame the ruling party.

Refuting the former AAP minister Saurabh Bhardwaj’s charge that the Delhi government had failed miserably to clean Yamuna uploading a video that showed dead fish floating near Sonia Vihar, Delhi’s PWD minister

Parvesh Verma claimed that the dead fish were deliberately dumped into the river by Mr Bhardwaj.

Contradicting the claim, Mr Bhardwaj said, “The fish in the river died, and videos of them have been uploaded on Facebook by several different people. Why did these fish die? Did they die because of pollution, or was some harmful chemical released into the water, contaminating it? The government must take full responsibility for this,” Bhardwaj told reporters.

 

“However, Parvesh Verma is claiming that Saurabh Bhardwaj dumped the dead fish into the river. But tell me, where would we have bought thousands of dead fish from? Would I have to go all the way to the sea to collect thousands of dead fish, or would they have to come from some major fish market in Delhi?” he added.

Responding to Bhardwaj, Delhi’s Environment Minister Manjinder Singh Sirsa reiterated that the AAP was allegedly dumping the dead fish in Yamuna River, describing it a ‘great sin’ while people were offering prayers in view of the Chhath Puja. In a video statement on X, Sirsa said the AAP was distressed over Yamuna clean-up and the cruise service that is operating on it.

“The BJP government led by Chief Minister Rekha Gupta has set a record by cleaning 60% of the Yamuna. Now, when they saw ferry cruises operating on the river and people posting videos, they became so distressed that they brought dead fish from the market, put them into the river and recorded videos,” he said.

Amid the ongoing row, the Delhi Jal Board (DJB) has submitted a complaint to Delhi Police, requesting an FIR against individuals spreading “fake news” about chemical dumping into the river. “As you are aware, the Chhath festival is scheduled for November 15 and 16 along the Yamuna River, when a large number of devotees are expected to visit the Chhath Ghats to offer prayers. It is brought to your kind attention that some unidentified individuals are spreading fake information on social media, alleging that chemicals are being sprayed into the Yamuna, disturbing aquatic life,” the DJB’s complaint said.

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular