Manas Dasgupta
NEW DELHI, Sept 25: While the BJP strongly criticised the opposition bloc INDIA preparing a list of 14 media anchors whose chat shows they recommended to boycott, the party’s Maharashtra unit chief Chandrashekhar Bawankule’s “advice” to his party workers to keep a tab on “nuisance-creating journalists” to avoid negative publicity has created a huge political row.
Bawankule’s advice delivered to the party workers in Ahmednagar asking them to “take journalists to drink tea… you know what I mean” diktat to party workers – to persuade them not to file reports critical of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, or the BJP ahead of next year’s election has gone viral in the social media.
Addressing a block workers meeting, Mr Bawankule is heard calling on the BJP’s rank and file to make a list of “nuisance-creating journalists” and monitor their activities and reports. In a widely circulated audio clip, he also urges BJP workers to ensure journalists publish only “positive news.”
“…small-time video journalists running news portals sometimes present a minor incident as if some blast has taken place. Prepare a list of such nuisance-creating journalists, and invite them for a cup of tea… so they don’t write anything against us… You know what I mean by inviting them for tea,” apparently indicating them to try to buy over the journalists to safeguard against any negative publicity. “Take them to dhabas. Treat them well and ensure no negative news comes out against us. There should be positive news about us. Protect your own booths first,” Mr Bawankule declared.
He also declared the Modi government had several notable achievements to its credit but that these were being obscured by journalists who “insist on publishing whatever wrong news they have.” The BJP leader did not name journalists but referred to “those from electronic media or print.”
Mr Bawankule’s comment provoked a furious response from the opposition, which has accused him and the BJP of threatening journalists to manipulate political, economic and social narratives.
Congress leader Vijay Wadettiwar, who is also the Leader of the Opposition, has led the charge. His biting response was, “Not all journalists have sold out… do you think journalists accept crumbs? I can understand the restlessness of your leaders… both at top level and local… as they could not suppress the voice of dissent! But now you have started directly making offers?”
Mr Wadettiwar also accused the BJP of trying to offer “crumbs” to voters before next year’s election, in which the ruling party is bidding for an unprecedented third consecutive term. The Congress’ state boss has ripped into the BJP for making journalists look “cheap.” “It is a devaluation of the media fraternity,” he raged.
Congress ally NCP has also responded; Lok Sabha MP Supriya Sule accused the BJP of continuing to refuse dissent in what PM Modi’s government has hailed as “the mother of democracy.” “Newspapers work as the opposition in a democracy… but the BJP state president is giving lessons on how to muzzle media. It is a serious matter and condemnable action. It is the BJP’s policy to not let journalists function smoothly,” she said, “BJP should admit it does not accept democracy.”
Under fire from the Opposition, Mr. Bawankule clarified that he only meant that journalists should be treated with respect and that the party workers should try to understand their opinions about the allocated booths. He said his comments were misunderstood. “Journalists are also voters. It is not good if you (BJP workers) do not meet… talk to them… or seek their opinion. I gave this kind of advice,” he said. “If news is negative tomorrow… we (the BJP) don’t have an opinion. It is your (journalists’) right.”
The senior BJP leader has also been backed by Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, who played down the import of the comments. “There is no need to interpret in any other way. Sometimes, when you are talking to your party works, certain things are said in a lighter vein.”
Controversy over the comments come after the BJP slammed INDIA for boycotting 14 broadcast journalists. The opposition alliance refused to appear on their shows as it does not want to “legitimise a hate-filled narrative corroding society.”
INDIA’s announcement was attacked by BJP leaders, including Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma, who said it proved the opposition’s “intolerant attitude.” He had also cautioned that the opposition alliance if came to power was certain to impose “press censorship.”